Section 4.8

4.8. Natural Resources Acquisitions.Property acquisitions involving natural resources—such as minerals, timber, or water rights—are subject to the same valuation standards as any other type of property acquisition.961 While such acquisitions may present particularly complex valuation problems for purposes of just compensation, “whatever the difficulties may be in making such appraisals with complete accuracy, it does not defeat the existence of a ‘market value’ . . . and it does not suffice as a reason to depart from the ordinary requirements that the law imposes on such transactions.” 962 Moreover, “the degree of speculation can and should be minimized.”963 Specialized expertise is typically required, either by the appraiser or through appropriate subsidiary experts, subject to the requirements discussed in Sections 1.11 and 4.12.964 Several frequently encountered (and often confused) valuation issues are discussed below. 

  • Section 4.8.1 Unit Rule and Natural Resources.The unit rule, discussed in Section 4.2.2...
  • Section 4.8.2 Highest and Best Use and Natural Resources.The mere presence of minerals ...
  • Section 4.8.3 Valuation Approaches for Mineral Resources.Under federal law, the sales c...
  • Section 4.8.4 Timber.The sales comparison approach is also typically the most reliable ...
  • Section 4.8.5 Water Rights.Water rights may have a substantial impact on the uses to wh...